Page 2 of 10
Posted: 8:42 AM - Sep 16, 2008
Dee Ann Buck
Genealogy is the collection of documents. You can collect tons of information on the issue of James MacKay Sr. who left VA @1830 for Jefferson & Switzerland counties IN. Many of these blood line's have been documented to the generation of your your John Smith's parents.
I am sure my distant McKay cousins' who lived in IN will benefit from your collection of documents, but I seriously doubt your efforts will benefit you.
Remember there were different groups of McKay etc....living in those counties who are not decendants of Robert Mackay Sr.
I see no indication that the lines of James Sr. removed to Bates Co. MO. It is this location you must find the documents I mentioned. Doing DNA test takes no effort and the monies who have spend on the test-- will be a "drop in the bucket" to the monies and time you will be spending collecting documents in a IN which you have not shown your blood line lived in the past.
The DNA test shows a Y connection of 11 generation to 20 generations or 231 years to 420 years. The male ancestor you seek could be back in Scotland beyond the reach of documents. So you can spend lots and lots of time and money collecting information dealing with Robert Mackay Sr. and his issue and none of it applies to your family members.
Lots of luck. Let's see you prove me wrong with paper documentation.
Posted: 8:51 AM - Sep 16, 2008
Dee Ann Buck
Here is what I have so far on John Dennis Smith
Rolla Smith Family Bible given to him by his father John Dennis Smith (currently in the possession of my father)
Birth date
Marriage date
Death date
No information on parents or guardians of John D. Smith.
Federal Census
1880 Hudson, Bates, MO
1900 Mustang, Canadian, OK
1910 Yukon, Canadian, OK
1920 Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, OK
1930 Yukon, Canadian, OK
Obituary 1946 "The Sun", OK (copy posted by Michael a few days ago)
Excerpt:
"...John Dennis Smith was born in Bates county, Missouri, March 19, 1851. His parents died when he was, seven years old and he made his home with relatives until he was old enough to take care of himself. During the Civil War at the age of 12 he carried the U. S. mail on a mule from Germantown, Mo. to Calhoun, a distance of ten miles, being assigned the task on account of the threat of Bushwhackers killing the men. He was married to Marietta Mendenhall of Appleton City, Mo., January, 1876 and to this union seven children were born..."
Obituary Oct 4, 1946 "The Oklahoman", OK
Excerpt:
"...John D. Smith, 95, pioneer Yukon resident and retired farmer, died early Thursday in his home...Smith, who carried mail during Civil war days in Missouri, was born March 19, 1851, in Bates county, Mo. He came to Oklahoma in 1890 and settled on a farm nine miles southwest of Yukon. Living there until 1908, he then moved into Yukon and had lived there until his death."
Birth Records MO
I have contacted their department and they confirm they have no data on births that far back. They begin to hold birth records around 1880.
Death Records MO
They also do not have any death records back in the 1850s.
Marriage Records MO
Requested a copy, but the office claims it is not on file.
Missing Federal Census documents
I have not located any John Smiths in MO in 1860 or 1870 that I can say with any confidence would be him. I will eventually need to trace every one of them to see if I can eliminate them. However by his own claim he was living with relatives in 1860 and possibly 1870. With a name like John Smith there is a LOT of data to sort through with little hope of confidence any one of them is the correct John Smith.
Death Record MO
Here is one document which looks like I have not yet tried to obtain. At least I don't recall trying. I will have to get on that one ASAP to see if there is any other useful information.
Kent Smith
You need to check your local L.D.S. library and look at the film for yourself. Clerks in government offices might not look for the information with the effort you do.
L.D.S. library has started putting records on line called Family Labs. I have already places a posting on this web site.
I believe I have found a John Smith on the 1870 Bates Co. MO, have you looked at all the entries on the census.
The Death Record you want to look at for yourself, line by line. There could be information reported by a John Smith on other entries which would give you further information. It is a must-- you have to put a names to those "relations" of your John Smith.
You might check State of MO Library to see if they have records on line.
$5.50 L.D.S. charges film rental for each film. There are hundreds of films you can order for IN and I have not check for Bates Co. MO.
www. familyseach.org The listing of their films on line.
I would not trust clerks of these court houses to get the records you will need. You will have to really put out the effort for yourself at the library.
Lots of luck.
Posted: 10:24 AM - Sep 16, 2008
Kent Smith
Genealogy is the collection of documents. You can collect tons of information on the issue of James MacKay Sr. who left VA @1830 for Jefferson & Switzerland counties IN. Many of these blood line's have been documented to the generation of your your John Smith's parents.
I am sure my distant McKay cousins' who lived in IN will benefit from your collection of documents, but I seriously doubt your efforts will benefit you.
Remember there were different groups of McKay etc....living in those counties who are not decendants of Robert Mackay Sr.
I see no indication that the lines of James Sr. removed to Bates Co. MO. It is this location you must find the documents I mentioned. Doing DNA test takes no effort and the monies who have spend on the test-- will be a "drop in the bucket" to the monies and time you will be spending collecting documents in a IN which you have not shown your blood line lived in the past.
The DNA test shows a Y connection of 11 generation to 20 generations or 231 years to 420 years. The male ancestor you seek could be back in Scotland beyond the reach of documents. So you can spend lots and lots of time and money collecting information dealing with Robert Mackay Sr. and his issue and none of it applies to your family members.
Lots of luck. Let's see you prove me wrong with paper documentation.
Dee Ann,
I appreciate your comments and I understand the principal in which you are speaking. However you mention statistics which are much father away from the data than my statistics.
From Michael's original post I will clarify the names and percentages. Based on the Y-DNA match between myself and Bibby McKay's brother, the following percentages are the likelihood of that person being a direct ancestor. The furhter you go back the higher the percentage likelihood. As you mentioned It is certainly possible that my connection is further back than these generations. However based on the probability that Michael is connected to Junior and that Michael is connected to Bibby's brother, and than Junior is connected to Bibby's brother, my DNA is so close to Bibby's that it is VERY unlikely that we are not as connected as she is to Michael and Junior. Therefore the chances are VERY high that I do descend through at least Robert Mackay. It is slightly more probable that I would descend through James Mackay and not Robert Jr. (Michael's line) or Moses (Junior's line). But is is certainly possible.
For the names and percentages according to FTDNA's statistics in comparing my Y-DNA to Bibby's brother I am likely to be a descendent of each successive generation based on the percentage show. To your point I may be a descendant of Rober Mackay Sr.'s father(s) rather than him. If that was the case I have nothing to work from since we don't have that data.
Gen 1 - Robert Mackay 79%
Gen 2 - his son James Mackay 70%
Gen 3 - his son James Mackay 57%
Gen 4 - his son Robert T McKay 41%
Gen 5 - his son Issac McKay 22%
But as I said earlier, the mutations between Michael, Junior, and Bibby's brother would normally suggest they did not all descend through Robert Mackay Sr. Again given that deviation in the data my probability for being related is Robert Mackay is much higher than normal mutations would suggest in the family line.
In the end I have been researching many different lines and so many people have helped me along the way. If my research can help others, I will feel good about returning assistance to the genealogical community.
Thank you so much for your continued support and concern for my wasting time on dead ends.
Kent Smith
Posted: 10:33 AM - Sep 16, 2008
Kent Smith
You need to check your local L.D.S. library and look at the film for yourself. Clerks in government offices might not look for the information with the effort you do.
L.D.S. library has started putting records on line called Family Labs. I have already places a posting on this web site.
I believe I have found a John Smith on the 1870 Bates Co. MO, have you looked at all the entries on the census.
The Death Record you want to look at for yourself, line by line. There could be information reported by a John Smith on other entries which would give you further information. It is a must-- you have to put a names to those "relations" of your John Smith.
You might check State of MO Library to see if they have records on line.
$5.50 L.D.S. charges film rental for each film. There are hundreds of films you can order for IN and I have not check for Bates Co. MO.
www. familyseach.org The listing of their films on line.
I would not trust clerks of these court houses to get the records you will need. You will have to really put out the effort for yourself at the library.
Lots of luck.
I have visited my local LDS center and met the staff last year. I have not yet spend the time to get the original records. According to the MO center, there are no birth records in the time period. I have not checked witht the LDS center to see if they are wrong.
I will check for the death record in OK.
I have seen a number of John Smiths in MO, but I have not yet gathered those entries to prove or disprove their connection. I will now go back down that path to close them out one way or another.
So far I am still working full time so I do what I can between tasks, projects, etc. Once I retire I expect I will live at the library. Maybe by then the films will be available over the net.
Thanks again Dee Ann.
KS
Posted: 12:26 PM - Sep 16, 2008
Michael McKay
Genealogy is the collection of documents. You can collect tons of information on the issue of James MacKay Sr. who left VA @1830 for Jefferson & Switzerland counties IN. Many of these blood line's have been documented to the generation of your your John Smith's parents.
I am sure my distant McKay cousins' who lived in IN will benefit from your collection of documents, but I seriously doubt your efforts will benefit you.
Remember there were different groups of McKay etc....living in those counties who are not decendants of Robert Mackay Sr.
I see no indication that the lines of James Sr. removed to Bates Co. MO. It is this location you must find the documents I mentioned. Doing DNA test takes no effort and the monies who have spend on the test-- will be a "drop in the bucket" to the monies and time you will be spending collecting documents in a IN which you have not shown your blood line lived in the past.
The DNA test shows a Y connection of 11 generation to 20 generations or 231 years to 420 years. The male ancestor you seek could be back in Scotland beyond the reach of documents. So you can spend lots and lots of time and money collecting information dealing with Robert Mackay Sr. and his issue and none of it applies to your family members.
Lots of luck. Let's see you prove me wrong with paper documentation.
There could always be a slim possibility that John Dennis Smith's parents weren't originally from Bates County. Perhaps his mother's people were from there.
It's unfortunate that there hasn't been any birth records or state records showing adoption. What I would want him to look at would be any old obituary information regarding McKay deaths during the period when John was a child and see if anything might hold clues.
As far as our McKay DNA testing goes what would really help us out in the long run are more participents. I am the only one representing Robert Jr's line and Junior is the only one so far representing Moses Sr.'s line as well as James line being represented by Bibby Appleby. We need more participants to get a better picture of the mutation sequence of all of the lines. Which ones remained unmutated since Robert Mackay Sr. and which branches showed a higher level of mutation.
Our family clearly has a higher rate of mutation since we have three confirmed Robert Mackay descendants matching the way we do and one possible descendant showing a close match with one of the participants.
More test subjects will develop a better picture of how this plays out like they are doing with the Valentine Hollingsworth DNA project.
Posted: 5:14 PM - Sep 16, 2008
Dee Ann Buck
It took me about three minutes to go to The L.D.S. library web site and find the following and they have plenty of other films of the right time period
Marriages 1860 to 1919
Court Records 1858-1885
Land Deeds 1839-1930
Wills 1843-1926
Plenty other general histories dealing with Bates Co. MO.
There is no "Brick Wall" in the way of his problem.
A "Brick Wall" in research is if the original records have been destroy in a particular place or time period.
I would still view the birth & death records offer by L.D.S.--for there might be informatin reported in 1880's by said John Smith.
Orphan reports are sometime report in land deeds or court records.
All he has to do--start filling out checks to the L.D.S. library--I do it all the time. $5.50 a pop.
Hundreds of film he can order dealing with records dealing with the line of James McKay Jr. in IN.
Posted: 5:24 PM - Sep 16, 2008
Michael McKay
I'm assuming Kent will see this. Since it stated he 'lived with relatives' I'm assuming the relatives surname was Smith. Now, here's the question: Was his mother's side named Smith? Or did one of his mother's sisters or his father's sisters marry a Smith and then took John in and raised him as their child.
I'm thinking that he would have been raised by an aunt an uncle. Why wouldn't that have been mentioned in the obituary?
There was a similar problem with my Arthur Jenkins who was said to be orphaned, however on his marriage certificate he lists his parents as Gabriel Jenkins and Mary (Drummond). I was always told he didn't know who his parents were.
Posted: 7:24 AM - Sep 17, 2008
Dee Ann Buck
I have visited my local LDS center and met the staff last year. I have not yet spend the time to get the original records. According to the MO center, there are no birth records in the time period. I have not checked witht the LDS center to see if they are wrong.
I will check for the death record in OK.
I have seen a number of John Smiths in MO, but I have not yet gathered those entries to prove or disprove their connection. I will now go back down that path to close them out one way or another.
So far I am still working full time so I do what I can between tasks, projects, etc. Once I retire I expect I will live at the library. Maybe by then the films will be available over the net.
Thanks again Dee Ann.
KS
I am assuming you have already check the marriage records for Bates Co. MO. The L.D.S. library as them on film.
I do not have the 1850 Bates Co. MO on line, the 1860 for Bates Co. MO list the birth places for Smith head of households as: AL, KY, NC, OH, MO (most) & TN. You will notice none for IN.
When you are pulling records on the male lines started by James Sr., his sons: James Jr. and Robert. Most of their legal heirs that lived in IN have been traced down to the generation you want. So you might need to check out illegitimate blood lines.
One blood line which I have not ruled in or out being connected to the blood line of James Sr., would be is "mulatto man Sam" Date of will 1797, so might have been 30 years of age ? about the same age group of his two legal sons. When I start going through the land deeds for Shenandoah Co. VA I hope to find out when James came to own said slave. Where did he removed after his freedom? Another bit of information I do not have. Did he follow the others to IN and then moved further west? The "white" heirs of James Sr. seem to remain in IN.
I do not have the time right down to check L.D.S. center if they have on hand information dealing with Bates Co. MO, perhap in the coming months I will find some time.
Good luck.
Posted: 11:15 AM - Sep 17, 2008
Kent Smith
Dee Ann,
(I may end up with two copies of this message. Somehow I posted it once but it did not appear.)
Your messages have inspired me to get my first LDS film and search for the marriage of John Dennis Smith and Mary Etta "Marietta" Mendenhall who most likely were married in Appleton City, St. Clair, MO on 5 Jan 1876.
She was living with her parents in Monegaw, St. Clair, MO in the 1870 census. Her parents had relocated from Durham, Hancock, Illinois in the last decade. By 1880 her parents were in Appleton, St Clair, MO.
I will have to dig into one fact that may or may not be correct in my data. I show that the first two Smith-Mendenhall children were born in 1877 and 1881 in Appleton, St. Clair, MO, but the Census shows John and Mary Etta living in Hudson, Bates, MO. Possibly Mary Etta went to her parents to stay while she had the babies to get help from her mother. Or I need to spend some time in the Hudson, Bates, MO data. I will have to dig deeper in that as well.
Thanks again for your encouragement.
Kent Smith
Posted: 5:39 PM - Sep 17, 2008
Dee Ann Buck
Welcome to my world, L.D.S. library !!
I did check today to see if there were any films or fiche dealing with Bates Co. MO--none.
A librarian showed me a on line site you will want to check out if you have not.
Missouri Historical Society
Has death certificates on line. You might want to poke around on it to see what other records they might have.
Good luck.
P.S. have you ruled out Elisha Smith on the 1850 Bates Co. MO as being the parents of your John Smith ? He is not on the 1860 Bates Co. MO. He was born in TN and his wife in KY and eldest children in IN and rest in MO.